Podcasts by Scary Stories To Tell On The Pod
Join SNL's Anna Drezen and comedian Andrew Farmer for an hilarious deep dive into the terrifying world of American folklore, ghost stories, hauntings, and urban legends, through the lens of the classic children's series Scary Stories To Tell In The Dark. Produced by the Forever Dog Podcast Network.
Further podcasts by Forever Dog
Podcast on the topic Comedy
All episodes
The Baby Cry Incident from 2021-12-17T08:00
Anna and Andrew read a listener’s tale of a mysterious baby cry and chat about the ghostliness of babies, crying and TikTok.
ListenPuffins, Cats & Moles from 2021-12-15T08:00
In this grab bag of an episode, Anna and Andrew read a farewell from Son of Owl Dad, a mother’s “The Mummy” memory and a chilling dermatological tale.
ListenPrissy No! from 2021-12-10T08:00
In this one for the books, Anna and Andrew read a shocking story submitted by Mara Wilson, about a train-hating, inn-keeping, cow-avenging murder suspect (and ghost) named Prissy.
ListenMiddling Curses & The Bodies Exhibit from 2021-12-08T08:00
In this jam-packed ep, Anna and Andrew recall the ethical horror of a certain anatomical exhibit of the 00’s and read a listener tale of an HR related curse!
ListenMINI-SODE: We Plunge Into The Turkey from 2021-12-06T08:00
In this special mini-sode (sponsored by BetterHelp), Andrew relives a Thanksgiving nightmare. Thanks to a turkey-dedicated hotline and some help from his friends, Andrew's dinner and ego were saved.
ListenThe Parallel Dimensional Phone Number from 2021-12-03T08:00
Inspired by a listener’s true mind bender of a tale, Anna and Andrew discuss the supernatural nature of telephones, wrong numbers and technology in general.
ListenListener Tale: That Baby Has No Face from 2021-11-19T08:00
In this toddler-centric episode, Anna and Andrew read listener tales concerning baby-monitor scares, cubed cheese and the ghostliness of sneezes.
ListenListener Tale: The No-Feet Ghost from 2021-11-17T08:00
In this ep, Anna and Andrew return to the vault of listener submitted tales to read one about a ghost with no feet, then discuss afterlife scents, undead vacations and Poltergeist 3.
ListenFaster and Faster (with Katy Fishell!) Pt. 2 from 2021-11-12T08:00
Katy Fishell returns to read the artful chills of “Faster and Faster” and discuss outdated horror tropes, perverted wolves and the classic work of art “Eight Legged Freaks."
ListenFaster and Faster (with Katy Fishell!) Pt. 1 from 2021-11-10T08:00
Katy Fishell returns to read the artful chills of “Faster and Faster” and discuss outdated horror tropes, perverted wolves and the classic work of art “Eight Legged Freaks.
ListenPost-Halloween Detox Minisode from 2021-11-03T07:00
In this little morsel of an ep, Andrew shares a personal post-Halloween tale about a ghostly encounter with a haunting rain-soaked specter in all black. Or maybe it was just a Mennonite. You decide!
ListenThe Hearse Song (w/ special guest Doug Jones!) from 2021-10-31T07:00
In this year’s Halloween Special, absolute icon Doug Jones (The Shape of Water) drops by to read “The Hearse Song” and discuss creature wants, silent movie monsters and post-mortem fingernail growth.
ListenThe Ghost in the Mirror (w/ Roz Drezfalez!) from 2021-10-29T07:00
Roz Drezfalez (Ghosted!) is back to reflect on “The Ghost in the Mirror” and discuss Bloody Mary the ghost, Bloody Mary the drink and Jennifer Coolidge the actress.
ListenA Weiner From the Other Side (w/ Special Guest Roz Drezfalez!) from 2021-10-27T07:00
Spiritual cousin of the pod and absolute delight, Roz Drezfalez (Ghosted!) joins Anna and Andrew this week to discuss non-denominational exorcisms, ghost grandmas and Catholic spookiness.
ListenMINI-SODE: Feeling A Bit Monstrous from 2021-10-25T07:00
In this special mini-sode (sponsored by BetterHelp), Andrew analyzes classic Halloween monsters who, let's face it, are just misunderstood. In fact, they could probably benefit from some better com...
Listen“The Little Black Dog” w/ Spencer Novich! from 2021-10-22T07:00
Spencer Novich (American Horror Story) is back again to dig into the four-legged horror of “The Black Dog” and discuss bad ghost dog owners, the myth of cats stealing the lives of babies and oppres...
Listen“Drooling Peanut Butter” w/ Special Guest Spencer Novich! from 2021-10-20T07:00
American Horror Story’s own “Pale Man”, Spencer Novich joins Anna and Andrew to discuss formative frightening moments, threatening audition tapes and the trials and tribulations of being fitted for...
ListenThe Wendigo Pt. 2 from 2021-10-15T07:00
In this long-requested ep, Anna and Andrew read “The Wendigo” and with the help of a gentle listener’s research, unpack the problematic nature of the tale, the harm that comes with appropriating In...
ListenThe Wendigo Pt. 1 from 2021-10-13T07:00
In this long-requested ep, Anna and Andrew read “The Wendigo” and with the help of a gentle listener’s research, unpack the problematic nature of the tale, the harm that comes with appropriating In...
ListenThe Red Spot Pt. 2 (w/ special guests Naomi Ekperigin and Andy Beckerman!) from 2021-10-08T07:00
The thrilling conclusion of Andrew's interview with special guests Naomi Ekperigin and Andy Beckerman (Couples Therapy).
ListenThe Red Spot Part I (w/ special guests Naomi Ekperigin and Andy Beckerman! from 2021-10-06T07:00
Very special guests Naomi Ekperigin and Andy Beckerman (Couples Therapy) drop by to read the iconic, skin-crawling tale “The Red Spot” and talk spiders, house centipedes and spider crickets.
ListenThe Red Spot Pt. 1 (w/ special guests Naomi Ekperigin and Andy Beckerman!) from 2021-10-06T07:00
Very special guests Naomi Ekperigin and Andy Beckerman (Couples Therapy) drop by to read the iconic, skin-crawling tale “The Red Spot” and talk spiders, house centipedes and spider crickets.
ListenComing Soon: Storytime with Seth Rogen from 2021-10-04T07:00
In Storytime with Seth Rogen, Seth puts his own spin on the traditional talk show
format by turning every conversation with each guest into its own little audio
documentary featur...
MINI-SODE: Summer Bummers from 2021-09-13T07:00
In this special mini-sode (sponsored by BetterHelp), Andrew considers the transition into fall, the regrets that follow fleeting summer months, and ruminating on expectations to have fun, even in a...
ListenListener Campfire Tales: The Misogyny Haunting from 2021-09-08T07:00
Andrew and special guest-host Rachel Wenitsky (The Tonight Show) bid adieu to Listener Campfire Tale summer with a horrifying tale including shadowy figures, weeping spectres and outdated gender no...
ListenListener Campfire Tales: Aunt Hooooeer from 2021-09-01T07:00
Andrew is joined by special guest-host Rachel Wenitsky (The Tonight Show) to read a listener's thrilling tale of aunts, surprise pilgrimages and The Queen of Pop herself.
ListenListener Campfire Tale: PhotoGhost! from 2021-08-27T07:00
In this ep, Anna and Andrew expose a listener’s deeply frightening story about a ghostly Polaroid then look into the history of spirit photography.
ListenListener Campfire Tale: The Ghostly Ballroom from 2021-08-25T07:00
In this ep, Anna and Andrew read a listener’s eerie encounter with a phantom orchestra and discuss the scariest music to hear from beyond, the perils of getting fit and the otherworldly nature of “...
ListenListener Campfire Tale: The Boy In The Tree from 2021-08-20T07:00
In this ep, Anna and Andrew read a listener tale about a boy who lived in a haunted home, across from a ghost-filled tree.
ListenListener Campfire Tales: Mysterious Radio Stations from 2021-08-18T07:00
In this ep, Anna and Andrew read a listener tale about an inexplicably strange radio station, then discuss other mysterious radio signals along with Russian espionage, hot mics and rotten breasts.
ListenMINI-SODE: Surrounded By Boxes from 2021-08-16T07:00
In this special mini-sode (sponsored by BetterHelp), Andrew reflects on growing up as he helps pack up his childhood home. Prioritizing mental health, especially in these spooky nostalgic moments, ...
ListenListener Campfire Tale: Haunted Cult House from 2021-08-13T07:00
In this ep, Anna and Andrew get creeped out by a listener’s haunted experience in a home that used to be belong to an impractically named cult, then discuss ghostly imaginary friends and red flag m...
ListenListener Campfire Tale: The Haunted Dogsitter from 2021-08-11T07:00
In this ep, Anna and Andrew read a listener’s hair raising paranormal dog sitting encounter then discuss undead obedience trainers and what the most ghostly cheese is.
ListenListener Campfire Tales: Arizona Scaries from 2021-08-06T07:00
In this ep, Anna and Andrew mosey into a listener’s tale of a chilling ghost town ghost tour, then discuss some more supernatural lore of Arizona and the unsung scariness of a classic sheet ghost.
ListenListener Campfire Tale: McRib is Back from 2021-08-04T07:00
In this shocking Listener Campfire Tale, Anna and Andrew are terrorized by a mother’s tale of a murderous sandwich.
ListenSummer of Sommers: Odd Thomas from 2021-07-30T07:00
In this last installment of Summer of Sommers, Anna and Andrew watch the surprise delight “Odd Thomas” and talk pre-ghosts, character walks and the indignity of working with bugs.
ListenListener Campfire Tales: The Phantom Camper from 2021-07-28T07:00
In this Listener Campfire Tale, Anna and Andrew read a chilling account of a ghostly camper from legendary gentle listener and camp counselor, Ayan
ListenSummer of Sommers: The Mummy: Tomb of the Dragon Emperor from 2021-07-23T07:00
Wrapping up The Mummy trilogy, Anna and Andrew discuss its third and final entry along with the disappearance of Rachel Weisz, the emergence of Michelle Yeoh and the handiness of helpful yetis.
ListenListener Campfire Tales: Evil Sugar Daddy from 2021-07-21T07:00
In this ep, Anna and Andrew read a listener’s disturbing late night diner encounter, then talk the horror of other people, mind-altering substances and Mariah Carey.
Listen“Summer of Sommers: Van Helsing ft. Paul F. Tompkins & Janie Haddad Tompkins" from 2021-07-16T07:00
In this blockbuster of an ep, Anna and Andrew welcome the spectacular duo of Paul F. Tompkins and Janie Haddad Tompkins to discuss the legendary Sommers film “Van Helsing.” All will be covered, inc...
Listen"Listener Campfire Tales: Rooster Foot and Stogie Cat" from 2021-07-14T07:00
In this installment of Listener Campfire Tales, Anna and Andrew read a great-grandmother’s account of headless ghosts, demon hotties, and piano-playing cats, then discuss the comparable magic of…Bi...
Listen“Summer of Sommers: The Scorpion King" from 2021-07-02T07:00
In this ep, Anna and Andrew get delightfully stung by the Mummy spin-off, “The Scorpion King” and discuss camel charisma, the magic of practical effects and the many talents of Kelly Hu.
Listen"Listener Campfire Tale: The Surprise Exorcism" from 2021-06-30T07:00
In this installment of Listener Campfire Tales, Anna and Andrew read about bathroom ghosts, witchy cats and the “massage to exorcism” pipeline!
Listen“Summer of Sommers: The Mummy Returns" from 2021-06-25T07:00
Soaring straight into the 2nd film in The Mummy franchise, Anna and Andrew dust off “The Mummy Returns” and discuss the thirsty mom demographic, were-jackals and suggestive quicksand.
For ...
“Urban Legisode: Haunted Cinemas" from 2021-06-23T07:00
In this Listener Campfire Tale ep, Anna and Andrew read a listener account of a ghostly encounter in a Wyoming cinema then explore America's other haunted movie theaters, complete with shoving ghos...
ListenRace Chaser Presents: A Brief History Of Drag Pageants (sponsored by BetterHelp!) from 2021-06-23T06:30
For this mini-sode sponsored by BetterHelp, Willam and Alaska - hosts of the Forever Dog podcast, Race Chaser - give us brief history of drag pageants and their importance to the Queer community ri...
Listen“Summer of Sommers: The Mummy" from 2021-06-18T07:00
In this ep, Anna and Andrew excavate their deep love for that icon of summer blockbusters, “The Mummy.” This one’s got everything: undead heartthrobs, pressurized salt acid and bisexual energy drip...
Listen"Urban Legisode: Haunted Indiana" from 2021-06-16T07:00
In this Listener Campfire Tale ep, Anna and Andrew read an Indianan’s account of a ghostly child haunting a home in transit, then explore other haunted homes in the Hoosier State!
For podc...
"Summer of Sommers: Deep Rising" from 2021-06-11T07:00
Kicking off their summer retrospective of Stephen Sommers films, Anna and Andrew squeeze into the 1998 sea monster movie “Deep Rising” and discuss the talents of Famke Janssen, the magic of practic...
Listen"Urban Legisode: Chicken Foot" from 2021-06-09T07:00
Kicking off their summer campfire story series, Anna and Andrew read a listener’s grisly tale of a chicken-footed pilot, then delve into the true horror of vengeful chickens, cannibal chickens and ...
Listen“Strangers" from 2021-05-28T07:00
In this ep, Anna and Andrew read the classic and BRIEF tale “Strangers” then talk casual undead acquaintances, the traumatic underpinnings of “resting Zoom face” and Cher in a ghost dimension.
...
Just Between Us Presents: Mental Health 101 Tips (sponsored by BetterHelp!) from 2021-05-28T06:30
The hosts of Forever Dog's "Just Between Us" podcast, Allison Raskin & Gaby Dunn, have been covering the basics of mental health during Mental Health Awareness Month. And in this mini-sode, sponsor...
Listen"Urban Legisode: Scarecrows" from 2021-05-26T07:00
In this installment of "Icons of Hoooeer" Anna and Andrew explore the history of scarecrows, including uncanny valleys, mistaken dead bodies and Batman villainy.
For podcast merch, please ...
“It’s Him!" from 2021-05-21T07:00
In this ep, Anna and Andrew take a swing at the murderous horror of “It’s Him!” then discuss unhealthy romantic relationships, scary medical professionals and Jerry Orbach’s eyes.
For podc...
“Urban Legisode: The “Love Has Won” Cult" from 2021-05-19T07:00
In this Urban Legisode, Anna and Andrew explore a spooky cult tale, complete with reincarnations, conspiracy theories and a surprise mummy!
For podcast merch, please check out Scary Storie...
"Urban Legisode: The Big Grey Man" from 2021-05-12T21:22:38
In this Urban Legisode, Anna and Andrew hike into the ethereal and ominous history of Scotland’s Big Grey Man, then talk optical illusions, Infrasound and Andrew’s famous (and very distant) Scottis...
Listen"The Bad News" from 2021-05-10T22:00
In this ep, Anna and Andrew run afoul of "The Bad News" and talk mandatory sports in the afterlife, male friendship and the difference between "Leon" and "Leonard."
For podcast merch, plea...
“Urban Legisode: Even MORE Haunted EBay Items" from 2021-05-05T20:00
In this Urban Legisode, Anna and Andrew return to their favorite habit of looking at haunted items on EBay, then discuss abandoned mansions, scary dolls that are trying too hard and even the possib...
Listen“The Walk" from 2021-05-03T19:44:35
In this ep, Anna and Andrew stroll into the repetitious terror of “The Walk” then talk scary story trances, haunted children hospitals and what faces are good for wigs.
For podcast merch, ...
“Urban Legisode: Psychic Scaries" from 2021-04-28T21:31:59
In their first recording in person for over a year, Anna and Andrew celebrate with an evening of listener submitted tales about psychic moments! Plus some nature hooer from a real life park ranger!
Listen“Old Woman All Skin and Bone” from 2021-04-26T19:00
In this musical episode, Anna and Andrew unearth the existential horror of “Old Woman All Skin and Bone” then discuss Mt. Everest corpses, Japanese decomposition artwork and Melissa Etheridge.
Listen“Urban Legisode: Theater Ghosts of LA!" from 2021-04-21T07:00
Inspired by a listener submitted tale of a vengeful theater ghost, this Urban Legisode has Anna and Andrew treading the boards of haunted stages across LA! Phantom pianists, lovelorn techies, undea...
Listen“Wait til Martin Comes" from 2021-04-19T22:00
In this ep, Anna and Andrew share exciting news about transcripts and merch, then purruse the feline horror of “Wait Til Martin Comes” before discussing childhood performance anxiety and cozy aband...
Listen“Urban Legisode: The Faceless Woman of Wai'alae Drive-In" from 2021-04-07T16:00
In this thrilling Urban Legisode, Anna and Andrew read a listener submitted Hawaiian ghost story about The Faceless Woman of Wai'alae (pronounced “vai" like Count Dracula saying "why", followed by ...
Listen“The Viper" from 2021-04-05T22:00
In this ep, Anna and Andrew dust off the classic tale “The Viper” and talk social horror, the widow archetype and the gift of wig identification.
ListenUrban Legisode: Incorruptible Saints from 2021-03-31T18:30
In this bizarre Urban Legisode, Anna and Andrew devote themselves to learning about the miraculous undecomposing bodies of Catholic Saints!
Listen“Clinkity-Clink" from 2021-03-29T07:00
In this ep, Anna and Andrew cash in on the all-time classic scary story “Clinkity-Clink” and talk bathing the dead, storytelling tricks and the fundamental difference between Meryl and Sigourney.
Listen“Urban Legisode: Ravens" from 2021-03-24T13:46:34
Exploring yet another Icon of Hoooer, Anna and Andrew take wing with an Urban Legisode dedicated to ravens! We’ve got decapitated oracles, birds cursed for fornication, weird throat noises and more!
ListenMINI-SODE: Life After Zoom? from 2021-03-23T08:00
In this special mini-sode sponsored By BetterHelp, Anna and Andrew discuss what it means for them and their socialization skills to maybe see a small light at the end of this pandemic tunnel.
<...
“Thumpity-Thump" from 2021-03-22T20:48:06
In this ep, Anna and Andrew descend into the chair-related hoooer of “Thumpity-Thump” then talk inanimate punishment, burying bodies and Cherry Jones.
Listen"Urban Legisode: Owls GALORE" from 2021-03-17T21:30
In this all-owl special, Anna and Andrew read a listener-submitted tale about deadly hoots, then glide into owl facts, owl fiction and yes, owl sounds
Listen“Is Something Wrong?" from 2021-03-15T21:30
In this ep, Anna and Andrew tumble into “Is Something Wrong?” then discuss fireplace hoooerr, trapped critters and accidentally breaking the Geneva Convention.
Listen“Urban Legisode: The Disappearance at Flannan Isles Lighthouse" from 2021-03-11T00:47:23
In this Urban Legisode, Anna and Andrew dive into some nautical hoooer and discuss theories behind the disappearance of three lighthouse tenders off the coast of Scotland. Was it a freak wave? A ph...
Listen“Cemetery Soup" from 2021-03-08T23:00
In this ep, Anna and Andrew take a sip of “Cemetery Soup” and discuss bone (and bone-free) desserts, strong female protagonists and the Barefoot Contessa.
Listen“Urban Legisode: Ghost is Angel & Angel is You" from 2021-03-03T23:30
In this Urban Legisode, listener-submitted tales inspire Anna and Andrew to discuss positive supernatural experiences, angelic subway riders and mysterious British scamps.
Listen“The Attic" from 2021-03-01T21:30
In this ep, Anna and Andrew explore “The Attic,” then discuss underwhelming ghost stories, the “Taily-Po” trope and Appalachian alternatives to Adirondack chairs.
Listen“Urban Legisode: The Green Children of Woolpit" from 2021-02-24T19:30
Pulling from old English folklore, Anna and Andrew explore the legend of the Green Children of Woolpit, then talk fairies, aliens, changelings and Kathryn Hahn.
Listen“The Trouble pt. 4" from 2021-02-22T23:19:56
In the 4th and final installment of “The Trouble,” Anna and Andrew talk Poltergeist Beauty Pageants, baby dolls and non-existent The Bride of Frankenstein musical.
Listen“Urban Legisode: Ball Lightning" from 2021-02-17T20:25:33
In this Urban Legisode, Anna and Andrew are electrified by the unhinged history of the weather phenomenon known as “Ball Lightning, which has left exploded churches, severed limbs, fried kite-enthu...
Listen“The Trouble Pt. 3" from 2021-02-16T23:30
In part 3 of their reading of “The Trouble,” Anna and Andrew discuss psychokinesis, globe fascination amongst teens and embarrassing dog barks.
Listen"The Good Ones Are Always Ghosts" (Presented by BetterHelp) from 2021-02-13T09:00
Happy Valentine’s Day! In this mini-sode sponsored by BetterHelp, Andrew touches on how the Vanishing Hitchhiker story actually applies to modern day romance…
Listen“Urban Legisode: Devil’s Hole(s)" from 2021-02-10T17:00
Inspired by a listener’s haunting email, Anna and Andrew descend into a few of America’s Devil’s Holes, uncovering drowned divers, cursed presidents and adorable pupfish.
Listen“The Trouble Pt. 2" from 2021-02-08T23:30
In part 2 of “The Trouble,” Anna and Andrew discuss haunted religious figurines, poltergeists and the spookiness of The Super Bowl.
Listen“Urban Legisode: The Haunted Escape Room" from 2021-02-03T18:30
In this episode, Anna & Andrew read listener submitted true tales concerning haunted escape rooms and a dad’s urban legend concerning leprosy bushes. Plus Anna confronts rumors about her being afra...
Listen“The Trouble Pt. 1" from 2021-02-02T00:50:12
Every Monday this February, Anna and Andrew will be reading part of the longest Scary Story to Tell in the Dark: The Trouble. In this ep, they also discuss scientific scares, Chilean stop-motion ho...
Listen“What Do You Come For?” from 2021-01-31T22:10:42.023393
A perennial favorite guest, Rachel Wenitsky (The Tonight Show) returns to piece together the tale “What Do You Come For?” before discussing scary attraction actors, Halloween pranks on children, an...
ListenRE-RELEASE: "The Hook" from 2021-01-31T22:10:42.023393
Anna and Andrew roll out the most classic of teen slasher tales, The Hook before waxing eloquent about Wishbone the dog, terrible boyfriends and the subtle beauty of how Branson Reese draws butts. ...
Listen"Scatterfingers" from 2021-01-31T22:10:42.023393
In this special Labor Day episode, Anna and Andrew bid farewell to summer by welcoming Andrew’s old campers and current comedians Annabel and Sabina Meschke to recount a scary story he told in the ...
Listen“Go Bowling or Something!" from 2021-01-31T22:10:42.023393
In this Kansas-inspired episode, Anna & Andrew read listener submitted campfire tales about a ghostly camel and the Satanic backstory behind the sleepy town of Stull.
Listen“THE 100th EP CREEPSTRAVAGANZA" Pt. 1 (w/ Ayan Karshe, Paul F. Tompkins & Mara Wilson) from 2021-01-31T22:10:42.023393
Anna and Andrew ring in their 100th episode with a 2 part SPECIAL! Featuring a tale of a kiss made possible by ghosts from treasured listener and resident Djinn expert Ayan Karshe! Plus “Scary Idea...
Listen“The Wreck" from 2021-01-31T22:10:42.023393
In this seasonal episode, Anna and Andrew crash into the holly jolly hoooeeer of “The Wreck” then talk holiday fire safety, trash gifts and Sigourney Weaver.
Listen"Urban Legisode: Not So Fast, Mr. Danger" from 2021-01-27T19:30
In this ep, Anna and Andrew read two listener accounts about the eeriness of everyday people, then discuss inadvertently cursed objects, the “Stranger Danger” mascot and retired gym teachers.
Listen“Bloody Fingers" from 2021-01-25T22:30
In this ep, Anna and Andrew unwrap the classic tale “Bloody Fingers” and discuss guitar injuries, hotel closets and Bob Dylan.
Listen“Urban Legisode: Murder Drill" from 2021-01-20T16:30
In this Urban Legisode, Anna and Andrew read a harrowing listener submitted tale of a real slasher situation with a twist ending, then discuss soup safety and different types of mom heroism.
“Urban Legisode: Momo“ from 2021-01-18T23:00
Surprise! It’s a two-Urb Leg week! In today’s ep, Anna and Andrew attempt to soothe a young listener’s fears of the dreaded internet bogey-woman, Momo. Weirdly it involves an Indonesian newspaper, ...
Listen“The Drum" from 2021-01-13T23:30
Welp, Anna and Andrew got quar-brain and accidentally recorded two Monday eps in a row, so here they are reading the mean-spirited cautionary tale “The Drum” before talking about spooky parenting, ...
Listen"Aaron Kelly's Bones" from 2021-01-12T00:00
In this ep, Anna and Andrew crack into “Aaron Kelly’s Bones” and talk toxic post-death marriages, the castability of Justin Timberlake as a corpse, and the long-lasting trauma of the trailer for th...
Listen"Urban Legisode: Evil Cars" from 2021-01-06T23:00
In this ep, Anna and Andrew rev up tales of evil automobiles! Possessed cars! Deadly semis! And Archduke Ferdinand!
Listen“The Voice" from 2021-01-04T22:00
In their first episode of 2021, Anna and Andrew reflect on the subtle horror of “The Voice” then recount Anna’s recent virtual session with a pet psychic.
Listen“THE BABY’S CROWNING! ASK ME ABOUT THE HAT!” from 2020-12-23T22:00
In part 2 of their holiday special, Anna and Andrew read more listener submitted spooky Christmas tales, about a beloved dog’s presence and a 6-year old’s reinterpretation of “The Green Ribbon.”
"Ghost-In-Law" from 2020-12-21T19:30
In this special holiday ep, Anna and Andrew read listener submitted true tales of ghostly in-laws and ghostly grandmas to ring in the Yuletide season!
Listen“Urban Legisode: Dead Grandma Zoom Bomb" from 2020-12-16T08:00
In this Urban Legisode, Anna and Andrew read a listener submitted holiday tale of a Zoom attendee from beyond the grave, then issue a correction regarding the legality of scaring a child to death i...
Listen“Something Was Wrong" from 2020-12-14T19:30
In this ep, Anna and Andrew drift into the existential horror of “Something Was Wrong” before discussing over-dramatic onlookers, ghosts on phones and the floating kids from “Salem’s Lot.
Listen"Urban Legisode: More Devils, More Dogs and More Devil-Dogs" from 2020-12-09T22:00
In this Urban Legisode, Anna and Andrew read a listener submitted holiday tale concerning a spectral dog, then discuss a real old English account of a murderous canine.
Listen"Urban Legisode: Frau Perchta" from 2020-12-02T20:00
Anna and Andrew slice into the folklore behind the Yuletide belly-slitter herself, Frau Perchta, then chat about holiday guest decorum and supernatural conflict resolution.
ListenSpecial Mini-sode: Harold In Session (Presented by BetterHelp) from 2020-12-02T08:00
Here at Scary Stories, we are fans of taking care of your mental health. So today, in this special mini-sode presented by BetterHelp, we put a mental health spin on Harold, the living scarecrow.
Listen“The Brown Suit" from 2020-11-30T21:00
Back from hiatus, Anna and Andrew tuck into the morbid horror of “The Brown Suit” then talk undertaker rules, what can and cannot be cremated and why you shouldn’t make jokes about ebola.
Listen"Zombie Grandma" from 2020-11-02T22:00
In this ep, Anna and Andrew read some listener submitted Halloween emails, including the legality of scaring children to death in Canada, a homemade Haunted Mansion, and an undead Grandma.
Listen"The Green Ribbon” Halloween Special!" from 2020-10-31T07:00
Happy Halloween! In this bonus ep, Anna and Andrew serve up a real Halloween treat: Alvin Schwartz’s “The Green Ribbon” from the book “In a Dark, Dark Room.” Other topics discussed include childhoo...
Listen"Urban Legisode: Goatman Bridge" (with special guest: Rachel Pegram!) from 2020-10-29T00:30
Special Guest Rachel Pegram (“Kenan”) drops by to discuss her childhood fears of “The Blob” and shares the legend of Goatman’s Bridge, before talking ouijia boards, coyotes and still getting poked ...
Listen"The Big Toe" from 2020-10-26T21:30
Anna and Andrew unearth “The Big Toe” then talk microwaves, jump scares and pig apologies.”
Listen“Urban Legisode: 1-Star Haunted House Reviews" from 2020-10-21T19:30
In this ep, Anna and Andrew read up on 1-star haunted house reviews then take a HARD left turn into the world of hyper realistic baby dolls.
Listen“Griffith Park Hauntings" (w/ Special Guest Mara Wilson!) from 2020-10-15T00:00
Special Guest Mara Wilson (“Welcome to Night Vale”) returns to the pod to share the haunted history of Hollywood’s Griffith Park, including the suspicious tale of a cursed picnic table, reports of ...
Listen‘Like Cats Eyes" from 2020-10-12T23:30
Anna and Andrew dig into the exceedingly troubling tale “Like Cats Eyes” before talking morticians, preferred methods of burial & the best funeral songs.
ListenListen to Scary Stories To Tell on the Pod Ad-Free on Forever Dog Plus from 2020-10-08T07:00
Forever Dog just launched a premium subscription service that gives you immediate access to ad-free versions of your favorite Forever Dog podcasts, including SCARY STORIES TO TELL ON THE POD!
Listen“The Blurry Gremlin" (w. special guest Kelly Nugent!) from 2020-10-07T19:30
In this ep, special guest Kelly Nugent (Teen Creeps) drops by to share three terrifying experiences from her past, including a gremlin, a drowned apparition and an octagonal room with VERY bad vibes!
Listen“High Beams" from 2020-10-05T21:00
Anna and Andrew shine a light on the classic horror tale “High Beams” before discussing Laura Dern horror, the healing properties of dog saliva and a chilling account of a vengeful fly.
ListenRE-RELEASE: "Urban Legisode: Kentucky Fried Rat" from 2020-09-30T19:02:28
Anna and Andrew unwrap the repulsive tales of rodents being served at fast food restaurants and other nasty surprises in take-out orders.
Listen"Grave In A Stump" from 2020-09-23T20:30
Anna and Andrew read listener submitted tales about mysterious phone calls and an equally mysterious backyard gravestone found in a tree stump in Rhode Island.
Listen"No Thanks" from 2020-09-21T21:30
In this ep, Anna and Andrew take a stab at the tale “No Thanks” then talk knife salesmanship, mall horror and the terrifying act of closing down an office at night.
Listen“Urban Legisode: Headless Ghosts" from 2020-09-16T16:30
Resuming their “Icons of Hoooer” series, Anna and Andrew wrap their heads around various decapitated ghosts/ghouls from around the world, including the Irish Dullahan, the Japanese Nukekubi and man...
Listen“The Bus Stop" from 2020-09-14T20:00
Returning to their literary origins, Anna and Andrew soak up the sensual horror of “The Bus Stop” before discussing Chris Evans, the history of “The Vanishing Hitchhiker” story and the trope of the...
Listen"Chocolate Bunny of Zelda Rubinstein" from 2020-09-09T07:00
In this ep, Anna and Andrew read an upholsterer's spine-tingling tale about a haunted chair and discuss Air Bud, small dog growls and the aesthetic creepiness of Catholicism.
Listen"Owl Dad: Part 2!" from 2020-09-02T14:57:58
In this rural-centric Listener Campire Tale ep, Anna and Andrew read a tale involving cursed underwear and prairie dog hunters, along with a thrilling follow-up to the Owl Dad saga.
Listen"Hydrangeas" from 2020-08-31T19:30
In this Listener Campfire Ep, Anna & Andrew read a tale of house-sitting horror and a chilling account from one of NYU’s many haunted dormitories.
"Joyce The Jester Doll" (w/ special guests Halle Kiefer & Alison Leiby) from 2020-08-26T07:00
In this ep, Anna & Andrew welcome Halle Kiefer (MTV’s “Hey Girl”) & Alison Leiby (“The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel”) to discuss their ghostly pasts including a tale of a chilling claw machine doll and a ...
Listen"Noodles All Day" from 2020-08-24T20:00
In this travel-themed Campfire ep, Anna & Andrew read 2 listener tales of hotel room hooeers including an impromptu Parisian exorcism, and a haunting message left on a bathroom mirror!
Listen"Pumpkin the Pumpkin" from 2020-08-19T18:40:16
In a roughly 90’s themed episode of Listener Submitted Campfire tales, Anna and Andrew take on a modern day nursery bogey, tarot pogs and a tub of haunted Beanie Babies.
Listen"The Dark Gift" from 2020-08-12T23:40:32
Annie and Andrew read a listener submitted Campfire Tale about a quintessential 1980’s haunting, and then offer advice on another listener’s question regarding their potentially deadly/helpful psyc...
Listen“This House is Putting on Airs" from 2020-08-10T21:47:35
Listener Campfire Tales in this ep include a door-locking, vase-breaking, dog-startling ghost and an adorable haunted house in Texas.
Listen“I Like to Watch You Sleep" from 2020-08-05T20:08:02
In another entry to Listener Campfire Tales, Anna and Andrew read a story about a vanishing phantom doctor, and offer advice to an Australian mom seeking guidance on what to do about her daughter’s...
Listen"Andrew’s Scary Birthday Ep" from 2020-08-03T20:31:33
To celebrate his 33rd birthday, Andrew shares a scary book he wrote at the age of 7, titled “Tarus and Nytmars to Trobl Yor Slep.” Plus, the evolutionary origins of the monster under the bed!
Listen“THE 100th EP CREEPSTRAVAGANZA" Pt. 2 (w/ The Warren Brothers) from 2020-07-29T22:53:41
Anna and Andrew close out their 100th episode special with pod-lore icons and Andrew's childhood neighbors, The Warren Brothers, who recount Halloween parties past, snacks of the late 90's and read...
Listen“Yor Are In Danger” from 2020-07-22T22:35:11
Anna and Andrew reveal the name of their new advice segment, and try their best to solve a listener’s haunting (or lack thereof) problem!
Listen"Angela Lansbury as Buffy the Vampire Slayer" from 2020-07-21T00:00:26
In this installment of Listener Campfire Tales, Anna and Andrew read a nurse’s account of a little old exorcist and an actor’s childhood story about an ill-fated church camping trip. Plus a ghostly...
Listen"Dead Mikey" from 2020-07-15T20:41:04
In this installment of Listener Campfire Tales, Anna and Andrew read a scientist’s account of a brotherly ghost encounter and a young aspiring graphic designer’s run-in with haunted werewolf clipar...
Listen"We Stan Medusa" from 2020-07-14T00:00:52
Anna and Andrew talk Greek mythology before reading some listener submitted campfire tales about a rapidly aging psychic, an eerie cyclist and more sleepwalking campers!
Listen“Space Camp Hooeers" from 2020-07-09T01:39:38
A true one-two of scares in this ep of Listener Campfire Tales! A scourge of sleepwalking campers at Space Camp and an otherworldly Beastie Boys fan! You can’t miss this one!
Listen"Porch Corpse or Woman Having a Nice Time?" from 2020-07-06T23:02:33
"Porch Corpse or Woman Having a Nice Time?"
Listen"Anyone Can Cackle" from 2020-07-01T22:14:12
In another entry of Listener Campfire Tales, Anna and Andrew read the harrowing tale of a ghostly railroad crossing and another about a haunted summer job in an abandoned mansion (complete with for...
Listen“GET YOUR SHOES. THE WAR IS COMING.” from 2020-06-29T22:55:26
Today’s installation of more Listener Campfire stories include walk-in freezer ghosts, sleep-talking boyfriends and a folktale of otherworldly romance!
Listen“Daytime Bravery" from 2020-06-24T23:15:18
More true creepy tales from you, gentle listeners! We’re talkin’ vengeful farmhouse ghosts! Demonic whispers! Phantom knocking! AND a disturbing update about a DIFFERENT kind of contagious nightmare!
Listen“STOP HER" from 2020-06-17T22:50:35
Anna and Andrew relay more frightening listener true tales, including one about a ghoulish motel specter and another about a harrowing message scrawled into the wall of an old shed.
<...
"Baby & Wind" from 2020-06-16T02:55:56
Anna & Andrew take some time to dive into user-submitted stories for a while, including ones about a hopeful (albeit terrifying) whispering harbinger and a camp counselor tale concerning sleepwalki...
Listen"The Church" from 2020-06-02T00:06:43
Anna and Andrew shepherd themselves into "The Church" before talking Parker Posey, ovine eye-shapes and being gaslit by 4 year olds.
ListenUrban Legisode: High-Rise Horror (w/ Max Jenkins!) from 2020-05-27T23:56:30
The one and only delight Max Jenkins (“Dead to Me”) shares his absolutely shocking true-life NYC horror story with Anna and Andrew then discusses urban legend murders, exploring abandoned asylums a...
Listen“Somebody Fell From Aloft" from 2020-05-26T20:21:33
Anna and Andrew sail into the nautical spookiness of “Somebody Fell From Aloft”, then talk New England accents, summer camp memories and vague lunch meat.
ListenUrban Legisode: Pokémon Black Curse (w/ Bowen Yang!) from 2020-05-20T23:14:47
Anna and Andrew welcome Saturday Night Live’s own Bowen Yang to share his account of the cursed video game of lore: Pokémon Black. Bowen gives a zoological take on how ghosts function in the Pokémo...
Listen“The Man in the Middle" from 2020-05-18T21:57:07
Anna and Andrew take the express train to spookiness while reading “The Man in the Middle.” Then, they talk real life subway horrors: Rats, unhinged blonde men, coyotes. Scary!
ListenUrban Legisode: The Bogeyman from 2020-05-13T23:50:45
In another Icon of Horror exploration, Anna & Andrew shine a light on The Bogeyman, discussing his international origins, the real mysterious deaths that inspired “A Nightmare on Elm Street,” and w...
Listen“Rings on Her Fingers” (w/ Rachel Wenitsky!) from 2020-05-11T21:30:31
Joining Anna and Andrew in today’s ep is special guest Rachel Wenitsky (The Tonight Show) who exhumes the tale “Rings on Her Fingers” before chatting about old-timey portraits, grave-robbing logist...
ListenUrban Legisode: Husband Scares from 2020-05-07T00:40:51
In this Urban Legisode, Anna & Andrew read tales from listeners with distinct husband vibes. We’re talkin shadow people, phantom door-closers and terrifying time loops. Scary!
“Alligators" (w/ Special Guest Oscar Montoya!) from 2020-05-05T01:29:19
Anna & Andrew invite special guest Oscar Montoya (“Bless the Harts”) to take the plunge with them in reading “Alligators” and talking schlock horror, thic alligators and the unbearable whiteness of...
ListenUrban Legisode: Black Cats from 2020-04-30T20:55:34
Anna and Andrew dig their claws into yet another Icon of Horror: Black Cats. Inevitably the conversation ends up exploring Egyptian goddesses, avoidable plagues and inevitably pregnant Sonic fan ar...
Listen"The Curse" from 2020-04-27T18:52:45
Anna and Andrew pledge the fraternity horror of The Curse before talking erotic hazing, branded broth and the origin of weekend water."
ListenUrban Legisode: The Curse Of Giles Corey from 2020-04-22T22:20:43
Anna and Andrew press into a reader-submitted tale about the Curse of Giles Corey and another concerning fortune teller premonitions that came true! Plus more Ansel Elgort talk cuz obviously.
ListenWondery Presents American Scandal from 2020-04-22T05:00
Join Lindsay Graham, the host of Wondery’s show American Scandal as he dives deep into the heart of the most shocking moments of fraud and deception in American history. In this six-part series “Th...
Listen“The Guests" from 2020-04-21T11:47:44
Anna and Andrew have a visit with The Guests and talk time travel, young Craig T. Nelson and the trope ...they died 8 years ago.
ListenUrban Legisode: Living Skeletons from 2020-04-16T00:56:03
Anna and Andrew autopsy one of horror's most enduring icons: Living Skeletons! They talk giant skeletons from Japanese folklore! Helpful skeletons from Central and South American stories! And the m...
ListenUrban Legisode: Witch Houses from 2020-04-09T01:51:17
Anna and Andrew follow the trail of bread crumbs in this episode and talk famous witch houses, inspired by a listener submitted tale about a real home in India, rumored to be haunted by an axe-wiel...
Listen"The Window" from 2020-04-06T19:57:38
Anna and Andrew sink their teeth into an ALL VAMPIRE episode, inspired by the chilling tale, The Window. This one has it all! 2004s Van Helsing! The sexiness of Bela Lugosi! And the unsexiness of D...
ListenUrban Legisode: Haunted Roads from 2020-04-01T21:48:17
Anna and Andrew take a trip on three of Americas most creepy roads before talking Robert Moses villainy, devilish numbers and a deep dive into what the Pringles mascots name is!
...
“The Slithery Dee" from 2020-03-31T00:35:07
Anna and Andrew squirm through the folksy origins of The Slithery Dee then talk Tremors, Reba McEntire and a user submitted tale about a ghostly nun!
THIS EPISODE IS SPONSOR...
Urban Legisode: Haunted Essential Businesses from 2020-03-25T22:06:13
In this topical Urban Legisode, Anna and Andrew patronize some haunted essential businesses, including banks and drive-ins, then talk broken ostriches, napkin-loving dogs, and a user submitted tale...
Listen“The White Satin Evening Gown" from 2020-03-23T20:55
Anna and Andrew take a whirl with the the disturbing tale The White Satin Evening Gown before talking prom dresses, the real dangers of embalming fluids and of course, Margo Martindale.
Urban Legisode: Haunted Paintings from 2020-03-18T21:07
Anna and Andrew dabble in the world of real-life haunted paintings before talking sleepover anxieties, suspicious ottomans and our culture's strange fascination with urinating sculptures.
...
"The Thing" from 2020-03-17T01:00:01
Anna and Andrew are here to help you weather through your social distancing by reading The Thing and talking Muppets, platonic male friendship and My Chemical Romance.
---
SCARY S...
Urban Legisode: More Listener Tales! from 2020-03-11T14:19:48
Three more listener-submitted scares await Anna and Andrew in todays Urban Legisode: a brief history of the djinn, an eerie encounter with an undead hoarder and a dare involving the infamous Melon ...
Listen“Sam’s New Pet" (w/ Alex Song) from 2020-03-09T16:30:32
Special Guest Alex Song (Its Personal With Amy Hoggart) joins Anna and Andrew to crawl into the classic tale Sams New Pet and discuss Canadian horror, Moms vs Mothers, and Jessica Biel.
--...
Urban Legisode: Haunted Ebay Objects the SEQUEL from 2020-03-04T12:30
Anna and Andrew click back in to the spooky world of cursed Ebay items! Genie rings, Cemetery Dirt, Leather Daddy Sex Ghosts and MORE! Make a bid...if you dare!
SCARY STORIES TO TELL ON TH...
"Hello Kate!" from 2020-03-02T18:31:51
Anna and Andrew waltz into the eerie Irish tale "Hello Kate" and discuss spooky social interactions and Ansel Elgort/Al Gore before getting one step closer to answering the mystery behind Anna's fi...
ListenUrban Legisode: Listener Stories! from 2020-02-26T15:44:32
In this very special ep, Anna and Andrew crack open spooky true stories that YOU sent us, concerning doppelgngers, babysitters in peril and a chilling encounter with the Tybee Dune Man. Scary!
...
"The Cats Paw" (With Mara Wilson!) from 2020-02-24T11:00
Special Guest, Mara Wilson (Welcome to Night Vale)joins Anna and Andrew to slink into the feline horror of "The Cat's Paw" before discussing mystical old Russian women, haunted blenders and the app...
ListenUrban Legisode: Ski Lodge Ghosts! from 2020-02-19T23:21:44
Anna and Andrew hit the slopes with three chilling ski lodge hauntings, then talk vacation friend drama, gay ghosts and an update on Annas finger injury!
---
SCARY STORIES TO TELL...
"A Weird Blue Light" from 2020-02-17T19:11:56
Anna and Andrew sail into the historically problematic chills of A Weird Blue Light, then talk Cheer, Ladybird and the mystery behind Annas finger injury.
---
SCARY STORIES TO TEL...
Urban Legisode: Australia Scaries! from 2020-02-12T15:13:57
In this Urban Legend from down under, Anna and Andrew take a listener's advice and investigate two bits of spooky Australian lore: the eerie story behind the novel "Picnic at Hanging Rock" and a fe...
Listen"The Dream" from 2020-02-10T11:00
Anna and Andrew drift into the iconic tale The Dream before talking Gillian Anderson, frightening Airbnbs and assorted bus decapitation stories.
---
SCARY STORIES TO TELL ON THE P...
Urban Legisode: Bad Creepypastas from 2020-02-05T20:12:40
Anna and Andrew log on to the less refined side of the creepypasta world, complete with typos, inexplicable character behavior and skeletons popping out galore. Plus the return of Scary Ideas for T...
Listen“The Babysitter" from 2020-02-03T21:15:59
Anna and Andrew dial S for Spooky in reading The Babysitter, then talk strong female leads, Carol Kane and ALF.
---
SCARY STORIES TO TELL ON THE POD IS A FOREVER DOG PODCAST
<...
Urban Legisode US STATES EDITION: “Delaware & New Hampshire” from 2020-01-29T11:00
Anna and Andrew crack into a user submitted list of the spookiest Urban Legends from each US state, starting with an undead physician from Delaware named Dr. Chew and the murderous history behind N...
Listen“Such Things Happen" from 2020-01-27T15:14
Anna and Andrew fall under the spell of Such Things Happen then talk transactional pets, The Queen of Versailles and hot veterinarians.
---
SCARY STORIES TO TELL ON THE POD IS A F...
Urban Legisode: Wall People from 2020-01-22T14:07
Anna and Andrew excavate a user submitted tale that will have you nervously peeking in your air conditioning vents tonight, then discuss moms, jungle cats and being 9 years old.
---
Urban Legisode: Jay’s Journal Pt. 2 (w/ Jason Hammons) from 2020-01-15T11:00
In this thrilling conclusion to last weeks episode, Anna, Andrew and special guest Jason Hammons (Chilling Adventures of Sabrina) uncover the secret behind Jays Journal: Satanic panic, a single M&a...
Listen“Scary Stories THE MOVIE!" from 2020-01-13T16:10:46
Anna and Andrew take a brief break from storytelling to finally review last summers blockbuster film adaptation of Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark. All that plus atypical bullies, cold stew eater...
ListenUrban Legisode: Jay's Journal Pt. 1 (w/ Jason Hammons) from 2020-01-08T15:47
In part one of this TWO-PART Urban Legisode, Jason Hammons (Chilling Adventures of Sabrina) joins Anna and Andrew to share his own disturbing experience with the ghostly lore surrounding "Jay's Jou...
Listen“The Dead Man’s Hand" from 2020-01-06T14:08
Anna and Andrew grapple with the social villainy in The Dead Mans Hand and share their own story about a recentrun in with a villain.
---
SCARY STORIES TO TELL ON THE POD IS A FOR...
“The Cat in the Shopping Bag" from 2019-12-23T18:07
Anna and Andrew bring you warm holiday wishes with this deeply unsettling tale of Yuletide revenge, before discussing holiday sociopaths, Long Island shoppers and the horror of scam artists.
Urban Legisode: The Yule Lads from 2019-12-18T16:53
Anna and Andrew continue their holiday-themed Urban Legisode series with a chilling look at the Yule Lads, a cadre of Icelandic monsters who wreak havoc during the days leading up to Christmas. Kee...
Listen“The Little Black Dog" from 2019-12-16T18:13
Anna and Andrew split hairs over The Little Black Dog and talk ominous canines, the blessing and curse of shedding, and actors who get typecasted as cucks.
---
SCARY STORIES TO TE...
Urban Legisode: Bad Ghost Tour Reviews from 2019-12-11T11:00
Anna and Andrew investigate the most scathing 1 star reviews (and owner responses) of ghost tours, then talk curse words, bad spills and candle accoutrements.
---
SCARY STORIES TO...
"Footsteps" from 2019-12-09T15:59
Anna and Andrew are in full wintry swing as they read the chilling tale "Footsteps" and discuss babysitting, Hugh Jackman and plastic surgery trends in the city of Aspen.
---
SCAR...
Urban Legisode: Mari Lwyd and the Yule Cat from 2019-12-04T15:22
To kick off the holiday season, Anna and Andrew crack open the legends of two holiday folk-monsters, the Welsh zombie horse known as Mari Lwyd and the child-eating Yule Cat of Iceland.
---...
“T-H-U-P-P-P-P!" from 2019-12-02T16:11
Anna and Andrew expound upon the comedic horror behind T-H-U-P-P-P-P! before discussing 90 Day Fiance, Pixie Stick Dares and haunted childhood basements.
---
SCARY STORIES TO TELL...
Urban Legisode: Haunted Ebay Objects from 2019-11-27T13:36
Anna and Andrew do a deep dive into the spooky side of Ebay, sharing the descriptions of Dybbuk Boxes, Vampire transformation rings and Werewolf transformation rings all on sale, before reading an ...
Listen“Just Delicious" from 2019-11-25T18:06
Anna and Andrew dissect the body horror of Just Delicious before unpacking bizarre diner orders, toxic marriages, and organ placement.
---
SCARY STORIES TO TELL ON THE POD IS A FO...
Urban Legisode: The Fresno Nightcrawlers from 2019-11-20T11:00
Anna and Andrew wander into the incredibly bizarre accounts of the mysterious creatures known only as The Fresno Nightcrawlers. What are they? Cryptids? Aliens? Or haunted pants?
---
<...
“Wonderful Sausage" from 2019-11-18T15:20
Anna and Andrew chew on the cannibalistic intrigue of Wonderful Sausage before chatting about the best type of person to eat, mistreatment of child actors, and the time Tyra Banks wore a fat suit.<...
ListenUrban Legisode: Lucy Liu's Sex Ghost & Other Celebrity Hauntings from 2019-11-13T11:00
Anna and Andrew crack open tales of celebrities' ghost encounters, including Lucy Liu's intimate relationship with a phantom, Leonard Nimoy's run-in with Vincent Van Gough's specter, and the time J...
Listen“The Bed By The Window" from 2019-11-11T05:58
Anna and Andrew wade through the horrors of old age in The Bed By The Window then discuss their own nursing home experiences, complete with secret passageways, communicable diseases and being repea...
ListenUrban Legisode: Ghosts & Dogs & Ghost Dogs from 2019-11-06T05:59
Anna and Andrew track down legends about ghostly dogs and the science behind whether or not our canine friends can sense beings we cant. Naturally this ends in a conversation about Minion hair and ...
Listen“The Wolf Girl" from 2019-11-04T06:02
Anna and Andrew chew on The Wolf Girl before discussing the non-IP haunted houses of Knotts Scary Farm, the rude sound design of The Lighthouse and Maddie Ziegler in general.
---
...
“The Haunted House” with Paul F. Tompkins! from 2019-10-31T17:25:08
Special Guest Paul F. Tompkins joins Anna and Andrew to recite the iconic tale, The Haunted House before discussing their mutual fears of fake demons, Eastern European ghosts and a possessed Winnie...
Listen“Room For One More" from 2019-10-30T18:34:03
Anna and Andrew contend with the grim horror of Room for One More then talk elevator/escalator accidents, garbled voicemails and too-big horses.
---
SCARY STORIES TO TELL ON THE P...
“The Girl Who Stood on a Grave" from 2019-10-28T10:00
Anna and Andrew plunge into the cautionary teenage tale The Girl Who Stood on a Grave before discussing their various adolescent Truth or Dare confessions and their shared love of actor and educato...
ListenUrban Legisode: Scared to Death from 2019-10-23T14:02:42
Anna and Andrew research the science behind dying of fright, then talk bodily phenomena, possums and self-important choir soloists.
---
SCARY STORIES TO TELL ON THE POD IS A FOREV...
“May I Carry Your Basket?" from 2019-10-21T14:51:42
Anna and Andrew dissect the various etiquette breaches in the chilling tale May I Carry Your Basket before sharing their fears surrounding joggers, Seamless and Lady Birds digestive tract.
Listen
Urban Legisode: Eastern State Penitentiary from 2019-10-16T15:05:41
Anna and Andrew investigate the terrifying history and famous hauntings behind the Eastern State Penitentiary, then exchange bizarre tales about heroic dogs, out-of-place magicians and a naked man ...
Listen“The Bride" from 2019-10-14T13:23:38
Anna and Andrew revisit the tragic tale The Bride, and discuss weddings, Halloween costumes and various injuries sustained during childhood games.
---
SCARY STORIES TO TELL ON THE...
Urban Legisode: The Foot Fetish Ghost from 2019-10-10T01:03:55
Anna and Andrew get their minds blown by a listener submitted tale about the ghost of a Brooklyn philanthropist/foot fetishist/all-around great guy who haunts people by making them...horny? Yeah, w...
Listen“The Dead Hand" from 2019-10-07T12:47:41
Anna and Andrew get lost in the deeply atmospheric story, The Dead Hand, before ruminating on crocodiles in the Everglades, sheds on Long Island, and accidentally showing your ass to Cousin Greg.
Urban Legisode: La Lechuza from 2019-10-02T14:23:49
Inspired by a very frightening listener-submitted tale, Anna and Andrew delve into the legend of everybodys favorite storm-summoning, baby-mimicking owl-witch, La Lechuza! Also in this episode: rev...
Listen"The Hook" from 2019-09-30T14:43:56
Anna and Andrew roll out the most classic of teen slasher tales, The Hook before waxing eloquent about Wishbone the dog, terrible boyfriends and the subtle beauty of how Branson Reese draws butts. ...
ListenUrban Legisode: Cemetery Superstitions from 2019-09-25T18:45:32
Anna and Andrew dig into some weird graveyard practices and follow it up with a discussion about babies at funerals, anxiety over getting raptured and the scary reality of falling into a septic tan...
Listen“Oh Susannah!" from 2019-09-23T11:52:27
Anna and Andrew marvel at the surreal horror of Oh Susannah! before dwelling on the dangers of raccoons in pools, historical re-enactors and the subtle genius of child-actor Stephen Dorff in the 80...
ListenUrban Legisode: Kentucky Fried Rat from 2019-09-18T13:29:10
Anna and Andrew unwrap the repulsive tales of rodents being served at fast food restaurants and other nasty surprises in take-out orders.
---
SCARY STORIES TO TELL ON THE POD IS A...
“Me Tie Doughty Walker" from 2019-09-16T11:36:40
Anna and Andrew crack open the classic jump scare story Me Tie Doughty Walker and also chat about unsympathetic pets, the danger of singing duets and the spookiness behind Lana Del Rey.
--...
Urban Legisode: La Llorona from 2019-09-11T12:44:46
Anna and Andrew dive into the legend of La Llorona, then stew over ice cream on airplanes, the pettiness of St. Peter and how damaged Disney princes are.
---
SCARY STORIES TO TELL...
“One Sunday Morning" from 2019-09-09T14:13:23
Anna and Andrew mull over the spookiness of church, sleep apnea and hurricanes while reading the very eerie classic One Sunday Morning.
---
SCARY STORIES TO TELL ON THE POD IS A F...
Urban Legisode: The Contagious Nightmare from 2019-09-04T11:50:18
In what might be their scariest episode yet, Anna and Andrew read a listener submission about a demonic nightmare that passes from person to person...by word of mouth. Are we subjecting the entire ...
Listen“Maybe You Will Remember" from 2019-09-02T15:58:49
Anna and Andrew read the mysterious tale Maybe You Will Remember then contemplate the horror of gas-lighting, international travel and being sixteen.
---
SCARY STORIES TO TELL ON ...
Urban Legisode: The Burke & Hare Murder Dolls from 2019-08-28T12:21:32
Anna and Andrew unveil the Scottish horror that is the Burke and Hare Murder Dolls, along with some spirited discussion about well-meaning little old ladies, the rules of being raptured and June Sq...
Listen“The White Wolf” from 2019-08-26T12:12:51
Anna and Andrew expound upon The White Wolf and then discuss animal psychopaths, Andrews childhood werewolf obsession and why Edinburgh is the scariest city.
---
SCARY STORIES TO ...
Urban Legisode: Disney’s Haunted Mansion Secret from 2019-08-14T12:24
Anna and Andrew recount the dark underbelly of Disneyland and the shocking truth behind just how many people scatter their loved ones remains in the Haunted Mansion ride. As one unnamed Disney empl...
Listen"The Appointment" from 2019-08-12T10:00
Anna and Andrew mull over the existential horror of The Appointment and compare the various ways in which they think theyll die. Sounds like a downer but its actually a ton of fun!
---
Listen
Urban Legisode: The Chain-Strangler from 2019-08-07T10:00
Andrew and Anna unpack the bizarre mystery behind a murderous ghost in Kentucky, before asking the tough questions about after-life clothing, haunted hotels and babies making telephone calls.
<...
Urban Legisode: The Three Men and a Baby from 2019-07-31T10:00
Anna and Andrew investigate the rumor of a haunting on the set of Three Men and a Baby, then react to the trailer for the film adaptation of Scary Stories To Tell In The Dark. Plus discussions abou...
Listen"A New Horse" from 2019-07-29T07:25
Anna and Andrew talk gay narratives and witch parties in Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark standout A New Horse," aka "A New Horse for Pride." Plus the one word that could bring all scary stories t...
ListenUrban Legisode: Bloody Mary from 2019-07-24T08:35:45
Anna and Andrew dive into the history of Bloody Mary and discuss hallucinations, teenage cruelty and the Duggar familys very weird term for deviled eggs.
SCARY STORIES TO TELL ON THE POD I...
“Cold As Clay” from 2019-07-24T08:35:08
Anna and Andrew kick off the first episode by exploring their spooky childhoods and the horror of prairie romance in Scary Stories to Tell in the Darks classic tale, Cold as Clay.
SCARY ST...