Podcasts by The Cookie Sheets

Episode 241: INCONCEIVABLE from 2023-12-01T03:19:19

Joe and Kurt are back! This week is all about the AEW Continental Classic, fallout from Full Gear, Survivor Series, and missing the old tag matches it used to feature. And that’s it. There...

Episode 240: Too Much Max? from 2023-11-17T03:36:01

Joe and Kurt are back, and this show starts off all about this weekend’s Full Gear PPV and the ramifications of the main event. Then it’s onto who the new mystery signing in AEW will...

Episode 239: He Won’t Win…Or Will He? from 2023-11-03T03:38:30

Before Joe and Kurt discuss this weekend’s Crown Jewel PLE, Joe needs to clear the air first.

The post Listen

Episode 238: Sting Says the Word from 2023-10-20T01:45:09

Joe and Kurt are back! This week they discuss the results and fallout of WWE Fastlane, before veering into AEW and Sting’s big announcement. Then it’s about the surprises of the PWI ...

Episode 237: On the EDGE of Our Seats from 2023-10-06T02:28:44

Joe and Kurt dive into Adam Copeland’s arrival in AEW and why he’s bigger for them than CM Punk. Then they get into Tuesday night’s battle between Dynamite and NXT for ratings ...

Episode 236: I Dream of WrestleDream from 2023-09-29T02:13:52

Joe and Kurt go through all the recent WWE releases and awe at the career of Dolph Ziggler. Then it’s all about CM Punk, Edge, and Jade Cargill ahead of this weekend’s WrestleDream a...

Episode 235: CM TKO’D from 2023-09-15T01:43:30

Joe and Kurt are baaaack. This week, it’s about the WWE-UFC TKO merger and its next steps. Then its onto AEW’s excising of CM Punk before talking other AEW exits and WWE returns! The...

Episode 234: GD CM PUNK ALL IN from 2023-09-01T02:14:49

Joe and Kurt are back, and in a fit of deja vu, are talking about CM Punk in a fight backstage instead of the actual AEW PPV. After that, it’s onto WWE’s Payback and AEW’s All ...

Episode 233: Biggest Wrestling Event Ever from 2023-08-25T02:00:35

With the show starting on a somber note, Joe and Kurt discuss the tragedies of Terry Funk’s passing and the shocking death of Windham Rotunda. Then its back inside the ring to figure out w...

Episode 232: Wait, they cut WHO? from 2023-08-04T02:31:16

Joe and Kurt are back! This week it’s about previewing this weekend’s SummerSlam in Detroit before talking AEW and ESPN’s list of top wrestlers under 30.

The post Listen

Episode 231: Heel or Face?? from 2023-07-21T03:35:07

Joe and Kurt celebrate Chelsea Green’s tag title victory before recapping Blood and Guts. Then, it’s the debut of a new game, HEEL OR FACE.

The post Listen

Episode 198: Exceeding Low Expectations from 2022-04-08T01:53:27

Joe and Kurt made it through a weekend of ROH, AEW, and multiple nights of WWE wrestling! This show is all about Wrestlemania: the highs, the lows, and the unnecessary.

The post Listen

Episode 197: Just Stupendous from 2022-04-01T03:16:51

Joe and Kurt gear up and use all their strength to preview the weekend’s wrestling, including ROH Supercard of Honor, Impact’s Multiverse of Matches, NXT Stand and Deliver, and of co...

Episode 196: Yelling at Clouds from 2022-03-25T01:55:46

Joe and Kurt are finally back! They discuss the formation of the Wrestlemania 38 card, play Old Men Yelling at Clouds, and chat up AEW’s recent happenings.

The post Listen

Episode 195: Get Some of that Chamber Money from 2022-02-18T03:18:19

Joe and Kurt are back this week, delving into an insane few days of wrestling news. Cody Rhodes is going from AEW to WWE. Stone Cold is coming back for Wrestlemania 38. And WWE is headed to Saud...

Episode 194: What a Wednesday Night from 2022-02-11T02:23:11

Joe and Kurt cover Goldberg’s return to WWE ahead of diving into an amazing episode of Dynamite.

The post Listen

Episode 193: Who booked these Rumbles? from 2022-02-04T02:32:34

Joe and Kurt whip around the latest wrestling stories, including Brian Kendrick’s insane 48 hours, before diving into the weekend’s Royal Rumble event and why it did not leave a good...

Episode 192: 2021 in Review from 2022-01-14T02:52:26

Joe and Kurt run through the latest news and notes in the wrestling world, including Mickie James breaking down the WWE forbidden door, give their “Best of’s” for 2021!

...

Episode 191: The Real End of NXT from 2022-01-07T03:31:50

This week is all about the real new era of NXT, discussing the releases of William Regal and a number of producers and trainers. New Year’s Evil is next up, followed by WWE’s Day 1 &...

Episode 190: New Year’s Wrasslin’ from 2021-12-31T03:04:40

Joe and Kurt dive into NXT New Year’s Evil and WWE’s Day 1 PPV events before tacking the IWC’s current debate: Randy Orton vs CM Punk, which is HOF worthy?

The post Listen

Episode 189: HOOKed from 2021-12-17T02:52:51

Joe and Kurt are here to discuss NXT WarGames and the future of the brand without top stars Johnny Gargano and Kyle O’Reilly. Then, it’s all about AEW Winter is Coming and the recent...

Episode 188: Cody’s on Fire from 2021-12-03T03:03:52

Joe and Kurt revisit the most recent WWE releases before discussing Cody and Andrade’s Atlanta Street Fight and this weekend’s NXT WarGames.

The post Listen

Episode 187: Shot Ourselves Into a Work from 2021-11-19T02:51:45

Joe and Kurt are back! This week is all bout Full Gear and the beginning of the Cowboy Era in AEW. Where does everyone go from here? And after that they dive into the possible WarGames teams ahe...

Episode 186: Budget Cutting to the Max from 2021-11-12T02:29:31

Joe and Kurt are back! Before they preview this weekend’s Full Gear PPV, they have to start with the latest round of WWE budget cuts and other head-scratching moves by the Stamford giant.<...

Episode 185: A NeW Direction from 2021-10-29T01:32:07

Joe and Kurt are back! This week it’s about the Becky Lynch / Charlotte Flair drama, the new NXT following Halloween Havoc, and the breaking news surrounding Ring of Honor.
The post Episo...

Episode 184: Right In the Crown Jewels from 2021-10-22T03:12:52

Joe and Kurt are back! They recap Thursday’s Crown Jewel house show, and then they discuss which wrestlers should change companies, and the explain why next week’s Halloween Havoc needs...

Episode 183: WWE Draft, Why? from 2021-10-08T04:12:13

Joe and Kurt are finally back! They dive into the shoddiness of the WWE Draft, NXT 2.0, and AEW’s next steps.
The post Episode 183: WWE Draft, Why? first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com.

Episode 182: All Over All Out from 2021-09-10T02:44:06

Joe and Kurt spend most of this week gushing over all out and diving into every topic imaginable, from the shocking debuts to the remaking of the women’s division. After that they dive into s...

Episode 181: CM Punk BAY BAY from 2021-08-27T02:25:34

After a wild weekend of wrestling, Joe and Kurt run through all the winners and losers from CM Punk to SummerSlam to NXT Takeover 36.
The post Episode 181: CM Punk BAY BAY first appeared on Mos...

Episode 180: Summer Smorgasbord from 2021-08-20T03:03:08

AEW Rampage, SummerSlam, and NXT Takeover 36 are all this weekend! Joe and Kurt whip through the biggest stories, starting with the biggest debut in AEW’s short history.
The post Episode ...

Episode 179: The Future of NXT from 2021-08-13T02:31:24

More NXT releases have led to a bevy of rumors surrounding NXT and its future. Joey and Kurt examine the future state of the black and gold brand before talking SummerSlam and the debuting AEW Ramp...

Episode 178: Around the Ring from 2021-07-30T02:36:27

This week, Joe and Kurt discuss everything in the wrestling world, from MITB fallout to Slammiversary surprises and the huge rumored names coming to AEW.
The post Episode 178: Around the Ring f...

Episode 177: Road Bash Fyter in the Bank from 2021-07-16T02:53:18

Joe and Kurt return this week to cover all the call-up’s, PPV’s, special events, and more from the recent weeks of pro wrestling.
The post Episode 177: Road Bash Fyter in the Bank f...

Episode 176: More Releases and a Watchalong from 2021-07-02T02:15:05

Joe and Kurt are back this week, diving into the most recent round of NXT cuts. Then they jump into the upcoming Great American Bash and Road Rager events before a watchalong of the 1996 Bash at th...

Episode 175: Obligated to Discuss HIAC from 2021-06-25T01:56:58

Joe and Kurt are BACK BABY. This week its about NXT Takeover: In Your House, Hell in a Cell, and new (or old) faces in AEW and NXT!
The post Episode 175: Obligated to Discuss HIAC first appeare...

Episode 174: Wait, MORE Budget Cuts? from 2021-06-04T02:07:01

Joe and Kurt are back this week, but before they dive into Double or Nothing they need to cover ANOTHER around of WWE budget cuts. And this time is even more confusing than the last round.
The ...

Episode 173: Double Your Nothing, Double Your Fun from 2021-05-28T02:21:50

Joe and Kurt are here this week to discuss the upheaval of the WWE announce teams. Adnan Virk out. Jimmy Smith in. Tom Phillips. Cody Rhodes and his “focus groups.” And then, they break...

Episode 172: Uh, Zombies? from 2021-05-21T03:33:31

Joe and Kurt are back this week, diving into the news from Wrestlemania Backlash. Then, they discuss all the NXT releases over the past couple days.
The post Episode 172: Uh, Zombies? first app...

Episode 171: Return to Backlash from 2021-05-14T01:40:34

Joe and Kurt preview this weekend’s WWE PPV, which is mostly rematches of Wrestlemania. Then they jump into the happenings of this week’s AEW Dynamite.
The post Episode 171: Return ...

Episode 170: Blood and Guts and Crash Pads from 2021-05-07T02:58:56

Joe and Kurt are back! This week it’s about the Blood and Guts match and all the…blood… and stuff. Then it’s on to NXT and the WWE product with Daniel Bryan’s free age...

Episode 169: The TNA Wayback from 2021-04-30T01:47:28

Joe and Kurt cover the weekend’s action with Impact Rebellion and the “impact” Kennt’s win will have and where the belt collector goes from here! Then, Joe covers his recent...

Episode 168: WWE Firings… and Wrestlemania from 2021-04-16T02:41:04

Joe and Kurt start the show by diving into the newly announced WWE releases and how broken up Joe is. Later, they actually discuss all the wrestling they’ve watched lately.
The post Episo...

Episode 167: How Much Wrestling Can a Wrestling Fan Watch from 2021-04-02T01:36:27

Joe and Kurt are here to get you as ready as possible for the multi-week bonanza / marathon of wrestling that is about to occur between Raw, Smackdown, NXT Takeover, and Wrestlemania.
The post ...

Episode 166: Fastlane is the Worst from 2021-03-26T01:56:40

Joe and Kurt are back to talk all about Sunday night’s Fastlane PPV. How bad was it? Then they aimlessly meander through the world of wrestling, including Andrade’s release and Randy Or...

Episode 165: Limp from 2021-03-12T03:14:33

Joe and Kurt recap Revolution, and the explosion that wasn’t. Then, they play everyone’s favorite new game, Womp Womp or Woo Woo!
The post Episode 165: Limp first appeared on Mostly...

Episode 164: Expanding Wrestling Horizons from 2021-02-26T02:46:23

Joe and Kurt are back this week to talk about Elimination Chamber and the set-up for Wrestlemania. After some NXT and AEW news, they discuss their viewings of Bloodsport 5 and Young Rock.
The p...

Episode 163: Shoot Baby from 2021-02-19T03:19:56

Joe and Kurt are back! This week is about real injuries, fake injuries, and real pregnancies. Oh, and NXT Takeover: Vengeance Day and the upcoming Elimination Chamber.
The post Episode 163: Sho...

Episode 162: NXT is Your Valentine from 2021-02-12T03:41:35

This week Joe and Kurt are all over NXT Takeover: Vengeance! But before that, they discuss the oldest Elimination Chamber match and the 24/7 Championship.
The post Episode 162: NXT is Your Vale...

Episode 161: Back on that Rumble Ish from 2021-02-05T04:46:55

Joe and Kurt are back! In this week’s episode, they talk all the results of the Rumble, what to think of Goldberg, Edge on NXT, Kenta on AEW, and wrestling weddings!!
The post Episode 161...

Episode 160: Only the Rumble from 2021-01-29T04:53:03

Joe and Kurt and back bay-bay! This episode is all about the Royal Rumble. This weekend’s PPV, the odds-on favorites to win the matches, and all the surprises that could be! Then Kurt takes u...

Episode 159: Declarations and Softness from 2021-01-22T04:11:22

Joe and Kurt are back! This week they dive into declaring for the Royal Rumble, the “softness” of current WWE, and the best non-Rumble matches on Royal Rumble PPV’s!
The post ...

Episode 158: 2020 Sheeties from 2021-01-08T04:30:02

The year end awards are here! Joe and Kurt move through the year in wrestling that was 2020. They cover TLD, Wrestle Kingdom 15, New Year’s Evil, all before awarding their 2020 Sheeties!
...

Episode 157: 2 War 2 Games from 2020-12-11T04:58:15

Joe and Kurt are back this week to gush over NXT Takeover: War Games. Then they get into AEW and the Stinger’s speech. Then back to GOOOOOOOOLDBERRRRRRG.
The post Episode 157: 2 War 2 Gam...

Episode 156: Effing Nuts from 2020-12-04T04:23:15

Joe and Kurt can’t contain all the wrestling in this episode. From Sting to AEW vs Impact, to Survivor Series to this weekend’s War Games, this show has it all.
The post Episode 156...

Episode 155: The Farewelliest of Survivor Serieses from 2020-11-20T04:03:59

Joe and Kurt break down why Full Gear was AEW’s best PPV so far. Then they get into the past few weeks of TV action before they address this weekend’s Survivor Series PPV, featuring the...